| 1982 |
Starting Here/Starting Now Jacques Brel is Alive and Well Amahl and the Night Visitors |
1983 |
The Mousetrap Marry Me a Little Wolf's Clothing Starting Here/Starting Now The Fantasticks Amahl and the Night Visitors |
| 1984 |
A Calliope Cabaret Post Mortem Jacques Brel is Alive and Well Lunch Hour Side By Side By Sondheim |
1985 |
The Unexpected Guest Two Knock, Knock |
| 1986 |
Ten Little Indians Perfectly Frank Run For Your Wife She Loves Me |
1987 |
The Burning Man Jerome Kern Goes to Hollywood Key for Two The Goodbye People |
| 1988 |
The Runner Stumbles To Whom It May Concern Cole A Bed Full of Foreigners To Gillian on Her 37th Birthday |
1989 |
An Inspector Calls Taking My Turn To Whom It May Concern Sing for Your Supper Our Town A Holiday Yuletide Cabaret |
| 1990 |
The Business of Murder Stepping Out Cheek to Cheek Off the Hook Romance/Romance |
1991 |
Night Watch Song and Dance Closer Than Ever You're a Good Man, Charlie Brown Death of a Salesman Rhythms of Life A Child's Christmas in Wales |
| 1992 |
Beyond Reasonable Doubt To Whom It May Concern Fascinatin' Rhythm Snoopy It Runs in the Family Scrooge |
1993 |
The Glass Menagerie Deathtrap Jerome Kern Goes to Hollywood Godspell Run for Your Wife She Loves Me |
| 1994 |
On Golden Pond Too Marvelous for Words Bye Bye Birdie Pull the Other One Scrooge |
1995 |
The Whole Truth Closer than Ever Guys and Dolls No Sex Please, We're British A Child's Christmas in Wales |
| 1996 |
Murder by the Book A Grand Night for Singing West Side Story Don't Dress for Dinner A Wonderful Life |
1997 |
The Complete Works of William Shakespeare (abridged) Stardust Oklahoma Key for Two A Chistmas Carol |
| 1998 |
Verdict Jerry's Girls Anything Goes A Child's Christmas in Wales |
1999 |
To Whom It May Concern A Grand Night for Singing The Music Man A Fly in the Ointment A Yuletide Holiday Cabaret |
| 2000 |
This Thing Called Love The Complete Works of William Shakespeare (abridged) Almost Like Being in Love Godspell The Diary of Anne Frank Scrooge |
2001 |
Scotland Road The Long Weekend Closer Than Ever Once On This Island Our Town A Christmas Carol |
| 2002 |
The Mousetrap Touch and Go Nunsense Oklahoma! Blithe Spirit Amahl and the Night Visitors |
2003 |
The Unexpected Guest Off the Hook The Fantasticks Anything Goes I'll Be Back Before Midnight Scrooge |
| 2004 |
Arsenic and Old Lace A Funny Thing Happened on the Way to the Forum Look Who's Talking The Wiz Deadly Nightcap Nuncrackers |
2005 |
Let It Be Me Build Me a Bridge FAME! It Runs in the Family 1940s Radio Hour |
| 2006 |
Up and Running! Gershwin, By George! West Side Story Spider's Web A Charles Dickens Christmas |
2007 |
Straight and Narrow Golf, the Musical Guys and Dolls I Do! I Do! A Bit Between the Teeth Bah, Humbug! |
| 2008 |
Ten Little Indians Too Marvelous for Words Fiddler on the Roof How the Other Half Loves Hats! |
2009 |
Love is in the Air The Front Page Same Time Next Year Oliver Bye Bye Birdie Tribulations of the Millionaire Wait Until Dark Nuncrackers |
| 2010 |
Love is in the Air II Cash on Delivery The Gin Game Godspell Les Miserables Robynn McCree Prescription for Murder Annie |
2011 |
Making Scents Shut Your Eyes and Think of England |